You can’t control the market. You can control the operation.
When a good agent leaves, the exit interview usually says “split.” In my experience, money is rarely the whole story. It’s the reason that’s easiest to say out loud.
That’s why we built The 8 D’s of Agent Movement. Agents move for eight reasons, and Dollars is only one of them. Now there are two free worksheets to go with it: one for you and your leaders, and one for your agents.
The 8 D’s Brokerage Retention Scorecard
It’s a one-page worksheet for you and your leadership team. Score each D from 1 (weak) to 5 (strong):
- Direction: Do agents see a clear plan, standards and priorities?
- De-Risking: Do they get fast broker guidance and compliance backup?
- Development: Is there real onboarding, skill building, accountability and mentorship?
- Differentiation: Can they say why clients and agents choose you over your rivals?
- Dynamics: Do people win together, day to day?
- Digital/Data: Do your tools and data produce measurable results?
- Dollars: Do agents know their true net after all costs?
- Dissatisfaction: Do you surface and fix agent frustrations quickly?
One rule makes it work: score each D the way your agents would see it, not the way you hope they do.
What your score tells you
Add it up. The total is out of 40.
- 34 to 40, strong. Protect what’s working, and re-score every quarter.
- 26 to 33, watch closely. Fix your two lowest D’s before a competitor finds them.
- 25 or below, retention risk. Your best agents are likely already getting calls.
That last line is the one to take seriously. Recruiters at competing firms are running their own version of this list. They’re looking for the D your agents feel you’re missing.
Use it to decide your next 30 days
A score without a decision is just a number. The scorecard ends with four questions you answer in 90 seconds:
- What will we start doing?
- What will we stop doing?
- What will we do more of?
- What will we do less of?
Run it with your leadership team before you set your next 30 days. Have everyone score on their own first, then compare. The gaps between your scores are often more useful than the total. Then pick your two lowest D’s and decide what you’ll start, stop, do more of and do less of between now and 30 days from now.
For your agents: Creating Your Future
The second worksheet is for your next sales meeting. It’s a ready-to-run meeting on two pages.
It builds on David Knox’s 8 D’s of life events, the moments that move homeowners: Diapers, Diplomas, Drive, Deployments, Divorce, Downsizing, Decline and Departures. The worksheet adds a ninth, Diamonds, for an engagement. The life-event D’s are Knox’s concept, and they’re a different list from the 8 D’s of Agent Movement above. One explains why agents move. The other explains why clients do.
Hand it out and give agents a few minutes:
- Pick three of the nine life events.
- Write down two people they already know living each one.
- Answer the same four questions: start, stop, more, less.
Each agent leaves with six names and a 15-day plan to reach out, partner and prospect. Nobody leaves the room with a vague goal. They leave with people to call.
Get both worksheets
Both are free. Pick your version and they’ll come straight to your inbox.
Free worksheet: Creating Your Future
Two pages to plan your next 15 business days. Pick your version.
Thanks, your worksheet is ready.
We also emailed you a copy. Check your inbox for a note from Mark.
Download the PDFWin the day.
Framework: The 8 D’s of Agent Movement explains why agents really move, and money is only one of eight reasons. The scorecard turns it into a 40-point check your leadership team can run every quarter.

Want help applying this in your brokerage? Book a 30-minute conversation with Mark at calendly.com/mjsession.
